Doing business became easier in
India and Pakistan in 2005-2006, according to a new report by
the World Bank and the International Finance Corporation (IFC).
Five reforms in India and two in Pakistan reduced the time,
cost, and hassle for businesses to comply with legal and
administrative requirements. No other South Asian economy
improved its business regulations in 2005-2006, ranking the
region last in the pace of reforms.Doing Business 2007: How
to Reform finds that India, the top reformer in South Asia,
implemented reforms to simplify business registration,
cross-border trade, and payment of taxes, as well as easing
access to credit and strengthening investor protection. Although
the reforms improved India’s ranking over last year’s, it still
ranks relatively low at 134 and lies 41 places after China-which
is reforming at a faster pace than India. The top 10 reformers
are, in order, Georgia, Romania, Mexico, China, Peru, France,
Croatia, Guatemala, Ghana, and Tanzania.
Doing Business 2007 also ranks 175 economies on the ease of
doing business-covering 20 more economies than last year’s
report. These rankings highlight significant obstacles to
business in South Asia, compared to countries around the world.
The top ranked countries in the region are the Maldives (53) and
Pakistan (74), followed by Bangladesh (88), Sri Lanka (89),
Nepal (100), and India (134). Bhutan (138) and Afghanistan (162)
are ranked lowest in the region.
The top 30 economies in the world are, in order, Singapore,
New Zealand, the United States, Canada, Hong Kong(China), the
United Kingdom, Denmark, Australia, Norway, Ireland, Japan,
Iceland, Sweden, Finland, Switzerland, Lithuania, Estonia,
Thailand, Puerto Rico, Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Korea,
Latvia, Malaysia, Israel, St. Lucia, Chile, South Africa, and
Austria.
The rankings track indicators of the time and cost to meet
government requirements in business start-up, operation, trade,
taxation, and closure.
They do not track variables such as market size,
macroeconomic policy, quality of infrastructure, currency
volatility, investor perceptions, or crime rates.
India, as leading reformer in South Asia, has taken over the
top spot from Pakistan in last year’s report. India cut the time
to start a business from 71 to 25 days and reduced the corporate
income tax rate from 36.59 percent to
33.66 per cent. A Supreme Court decision made enforcing
collateral simpler-easing access to credit. New risk management
procedures in customs lowered import time by two days and
exports by nine days. And reforms to stock exchange rules
toughened investor protections. Pakistan was the runner-up
reformer in South Asia this year. Reforms to modernize customs
reduced time to import from 39 to 15 days and time to export
from 33 to 24 days. Corporate tax rates fell from 39 percent in
2004 to 37 percent in 2005 and 35 percent in 2006. Bangladesh
also reformed, introducing a new land registration act to
improve security and reduce corruption in land transactions.
"More such progress is needed. South Asian countries would
greatly benefit from new enterprises and jobs, which can come
with more business-friendly regulations," said Michael Klein,
World Bank-IFC vice president for financial and private sector
development, and IFC chief economist.
The report finds that the South Asia region ranks behind all
others on the pace of reforms, with only a quarter of countries
making at least one reform that improved the Doing Business
indicators. And two-Sri Lanka and the Maldives-made doing
business more difficult. Sri Lanka reintroduced stamp duty and
levied a new tax on profits. Maldives now requires a mandatory
two-month notice period before workers can be dismissed, a move
that may especially discourage small business and the hiring of
poor, low-skilled, and young workers.
The report finds that the greatest remaining obstacles in the
region are slow courts and rigid labor laws. For example, in
Bangladesh, enforcing a simple commercial contract through the
courts takes 50 procedures and 1,442 days. In Sri Lanka, an
employer must pay 178 weeks in severance to dismiss a redundant
worker. The less flexible the labor regulations, the more
business hires informally, paying lower wages and avoiding
benefits. In fact by one estimate, in India there are only 30
million formal sector jobs, out of a population of 1.1 billion.
Doing Business allows policymakers to compare regulatory
performance with other countries, learn from best practices
globally, and prioritize reforms. "The annual Doing Business
updates have already had an impact. The analysis has inspired
and informed at least 48 reforms around the world. The
lesson-what gets measured gets done," said Caralee McLiesh, an
author of the report.
Globally the most popular reform in 2005-2006 was easing the
regulations of business start-up. Forty-three countries
simplified procedures, reducing costs and delays. The second
most popular reform-implemented in 31 countries-was reducing tax
rates and the administrative hassle of paying taxes.
Whatever reformers do, they should always ask the question,
Who will benefit the most? If reforms are seen to benefit only
foreign investors, or large investors, or
bureaucrats-turned-investors, they reduce the legitimacy of the
government. "Reforms should ease the burden on all businesses:
small and large, domestic and foreign, rural and urban. This way
there is no need to guess where the next boom in jobs will come
from. Any business will have the opportunity to thrive," said
Simeon Djankov, an author of the report.