Prima originally operated as a contract miller
when the flourmill was built in 1977 under a
Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) Agreement signed with the
Government but the BOT Agreement never restricted or prevented
the Government from constructing additional flourmills or any
other party from building further flourmills.
Prima's role was to mill the wheat that was
bought by the Government. Besides buying the wheat, the
Government was entirely responsible for setting the selling
price of the flour, and selling and distributing the flour.
Hence the Government solely operated the flour business.
Therefore, as Prima was merely a contract
miller, and as explained above, additional flourmills were
allowed, there was no monopoly conferred on Prima by the
Government. In fact, the Government itself operated the entire
flour business.
The BOT Agreement was to expire at the end of
December 2005.
By 2000, the Government felt that the flour
industry had matured and should be totally liberalized. Also the
Government did not want to continue to shoulder the burden and
responsibility to operate the flour business, and was looking to
privatize the business.
However, without first terminating the BOT
arrangements, it was not possible for the Government to proceed
with their plans. Under BOT, the Government could not relinquish
its obligation in providing, selling and distribution of flour,
and import of flour was disallowed.
Hence, even though the BOT arrangements would
only terminate at the end of 2005, the Government approached
Prima in 2000 to broach the termination of the BOT.
Although Prima had stood to lose five years of
steady BOT operations, it conceded to the Government's request
so that it could proceed with its privatization and
liberalization programme.
Therefore after many months of serious
discussions with the Government, the operation of Prima's
flourmill was converted from BOT to Build-Own-Operate (BOO) with
effect from 21 June 2001.
The Government was so happy and proud of its
achievement that it called a press conference to announce the
terms of the new BOO Agreement that it had signed with Prima.
The newspapers and the media reports published
on or around 27 April 2001 stated that the Government was of the
view that the new initiatives had far reaching benefits to the
Government, its fiscal management, the consumer and the food
industry in general. (vide advertisement published on this page)
As can be seen, Prima had been cooperative with
the Government, and had even facilitated the Government's
liberalization programme by agreeing to terminate the BOT
Agreement five years before its expiry date.
Hence it is obvious that Prima was not against
or afraid of competition. Prima accepts competition provided
that it is fair competition.
All that was asked of the Government was that it
ensures that there will be level playing field and no
discrimination especially in that no party would be favoured at
the expense of the Government. To ensure an orderly market, the
Government should have in place anti-dumping or unfair trade
practices legislations.
From its pioneering BOT days in 1977 till the
present BOO operations, Prima had made many significant
socio-economic contributions to the Government and people by its
presence and operations in the country.
The country had managed to achieve complete
import substitution in wheat flour, thereby saving substantial
foreign exchange.
Through Prima's advice in structuring of the BOT
arrangements, the Government was able to enjoy the benefits of
the various Government to Government aid wheat programmes. These
totaled about US$ 1.1 billion during the period 1980 - 2001 from
USA, Canada and Australia.
In an extract of the World Bank Report of 1982,
the World Bank stated that the commissioning of the Prima mill
at Trincomalee contributed to the reduction of the current
account deficit in Sri Lanka.
Converting from BOT to BOO also netted the
Government significant benefits:
Cash payment of US$ 65 million was made to the
Government in June 2001.
The Government was at an advantage to make use
of US$ 65 million without itself being burdened with financing
the interest and the costs of borrowing which would have been
charged by the financial institutions.
The Government was freed from the
financial burdens in maintaining stockpiles of wheat grain,
wheat flour and other supplies, which amounted at that time to
about USD 60 million. Indeed, based on today's wheat prices,
this financial burden would exceed USD 120 million.
The Government also freed itself from the risk
of any loss arising from terrorists' attacks on the wheat
consignments or damage to vessels and cargo during the voyage.
It is significant to note Sri Lanka is in the list of countries
with on going war and therefore additional war risk premium
coverage will be required.
Additionally, Prima now bears all the risk of
adverse fluctuations in the exchange rate and price of wheat
grain.
The Government was also freed from all
commercial disputes with the wheat sellers and shipping disputes
with vessel owners.
In terms of the benefit to the consumers in Sri
Lanka, with the efficient distribution network established by
Prima, fresh wheat flour was available and delivered to
consumers' doorsteps. In addition, quality was maintained
without deterioration as flour was no longer kept for months in
Government's warehouses. Consumers had a choice of some 7 new
types of flour as opposed to 3 previously and short-weight and
pilferage had totally stopped.
Besides paying USD 65 million upfront to the
Government, Prima also invested an additional USD 30 million
since 2001 to upgrade and expand its flourmill and logistic
infrastructure. This is to enable the milling and distribution
operations to be made more efficient and productive to ensure an
adequate supply of most competitively priced wheat flour to the
people.
With this not only has Prima enabled Sri Lanka
to be comfortably self-sufficient in wheat flour, but also for
the very first time in Sri Lanka's history, Prima has been able
to export wheat flour, in significant quantities. About 20% of
Prima's milling capacity can be devoted to exports.
In 2006, export of wheat flour amounted to USD
46 million, and for this year up till now, Prima has exported to
the value of USD 35 million. This USD 81 million is indeed a
welcome boost to the country's foreign exchange reserve.
To put the size of these maiden exports in
perspective, it is interesting to compare it with some of Sri
Lanka's established exports. For 2006, Prima's flour exports in
value were about 50% of total rubber exports, and about 5% of
total tea exports. This is certainly a very good start for Sri
Lanka and Prima.